ethanblair's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[AMERICAN BALLFROG]

I Appreciate The Time Scale Of The Animateion Its A Standard Of How Long Most New Grounds Animateions Should Be That Being Said Its With A Heavy Heart I Say This Was Not Very Funny I See What You Were Going For Like Sarcastic Funny Humor Though Its Very Difficult To Pull Off And What You Guys Had To Work With You Did Fairly Well The Humor Is A Bit Stale Though The Animateion While Not Out Standing Is Still Pretty Great I Hate As A Styleistic Choice The Phones Clipped Through The Ground Which Kind Of Killed The Experience As I Believe Even Over The Top Cartoons Follow Some Sort Reality Based Logics Its Not Just The Phones The Character Models Are Not Pleaseing To Look At It Looks Off It Feels Kind Of Forced And Generic Its A Good Animateion But Not A Great Animateion The Background Is Decent Though Could Be More Createive Scenery Overall This Is A Flawwed But Good Animateion Deserveing Of Three And A Half Stars

BrandyBuizel responds:

This is kind of hard to read in Pascal Case

[Join me, Ballfrog]

Well That Was Pretty Interesting Theres Very Little Here But What Is Here Happens To Be Really Good Stuff But That Being Said I Wish It Was Longer With A Few More Charming Moments You Would Benefit More From Longer Animateions

Merol responds:

Thank you! I do plan to make longer animations.

[🔴 and 🟡]

This Is An Incredible Animateion Its Simple Animateion And Symbolism Is Neat I Think The Few Words Exchange Kind Of Ruins The Mood But I Like How It Ambiguously Tells A Story About Growing A Part Well Done Four Stars

[Give Lasagna]

Ehhhhhhh Its Definitely Open For Improvement Its Not Terrible But Just Really Quick And Boreing Though I Commend The Animateion

[Spirit Bakery]

I Really Liked The Animateion It Was Not Flawless But Pretty Good It Reminded Me Of Studio Gibli A Few Thing I Found Off Was The Close Up Of The Baker Was To Close And A Bit Rough AndThe Smileing And Eating Bit Looked Off I Wished It Was More Wholesome Still Pretty Good

[What a Dirty Cat]

Thats One Dirty Pussy Great Animateion

AlternateBazaarArt responds:

The dirtiest. Thank you!

[PAD THAI [FAN ANIMATION]]

i Have No Idea What That Was From But It Was Pretty Cool

[ASDFComp 1]

Could Be Better Way More Effort Is Needed

OdetteTheAnimator07 responds:

Yeah, don't worry! It will be better soon! :D